Acupuncture and endorphins

Han J-S · Neuroscience Letters · 2004

🔬Experimental Mini-Review👥Multiple studiesHigh Scientific Impact

Evidence Level

STRONG
85/ 100
Quality
5/5
Sample
4/5
Replication
5/5
🎯

OBJECTIVE

To investigate how electroacupuncture releases different endogenous opioid peptides in the central nervous system to produce analgesia

👥

WHO

Animal studies (rats and rabbits) and validation in patients with chronic pain, low back pain, and diabetic neuropathy

⏱️

DURATION

Research developed over several decades (1950s-2000s)

📍

POINTS

Electrical stimulation at peripheral acupoints with different frequencies (2 Hz, 15 Hz, 100 Hz)

🔬 Study Design

0participants
randomization

EA 2 Hz

n=0

low-frequency electroacupuncture

EA 100 Hz

n=0

high-frequency electroacupuncture

Alternating EA 2/100 Hz

n=0

electroacupuncture with alternating frequencies

⏱️ Duration: Multiple experimental studies

📊 Results in numbers

7x greater

Enkephalin release with EA 2 Hz

2x greater

Dynorphin release with EA 100 Hz

0%

Postoperative morphine reduction (alternating mode)

32-35%

Morphine reduction (fixed frequency)

Percentage highlights

53%
Postoperative morphine reduction (alternating mode)
32-35%
Morphine reduction (fixed frequency)

📊 Outcome Comparison

Opioid peptide release

EA 2 Hz
7
EA 100 Hz
2
Alternating EA
9
💬 What does this mean for you?

This study explains how acupuncture with electrical stimulation works in the body to relieve pain. The research showed that different stimulation frequencies release different natural analgesic substances in our nervous system, and that combining these frequencies can produce more effective pain relief than using a single frequency.

📝

Article summary

Plain-language narrative summary

Acupuncture, a centuries-old practice of traditional Chinese medicine, has attracted growing interest from the international scientific community, particularly for the treatment of acute and chronic pain. Although it has been used for thousands of years, only in recent decades have investigators begun to understand the scientific mechanisms that explain its therapeutic effects. One of the most intriguing aspects of this technique is how the insertion of needles at specific body points can produce pain relief, leading scientists to investigate the neurobiological processes involved in depth. This understanding is fundamental not only for the scientific validation of acupuncture, but also for optimizing its treatment protocols and expanding its clinical applications in a responsible, evidence-based manner.

The study conducted by the renowned investigator Ji-Sheng Han, of the Neuroscience Institute of Peking University, aimed primarily to elucidate the mechanisms by which electroacupuncture produces analgesia, with particular focus on the role of endorphins and other natural opioid peptides of the organism. The research used a comprehensive methodological approach, combining experiments in laboratory animals with clinical studies in humans. Investigators employed different electrical stimulation frequencies applied through acupuncture needles, varying between 2 Hz, 15 Hz, and 100 Hz, to investigate how each frequency affects the release of different analgesic substances in the central nervous system. To measure the effects, they used pain threshold tests in animals, analysis of cerebrospinal fluid via radioimmunoassay techniques, and clinically assessed the reduction of analgesic consumption in patients undergoing surgery.

The results revealed surprising findings regarding how different frequencies of electrical stimulation activate distinct systems of natural pain relief. When electroacupuncture was applied at low frequency, specifically 2 Hz, a significant increase was observed in the release of enkephalins, beta-endorphins, and endomorphins, which are natural substances of the body with potent analgesic effects. By contrast, high-frequency stimulation at 100 Hz preferentially produced the release of dynorphins, another type of endogenous opioid peptide. The intermediate frequency of 15 Hz showed partial activation of both systems.

Even more striking was the discovery that the alternating combination of low and high frequencies, applied in cycles of 3 seconds each, resulted in the simultaneous release of all four types of endogenous opioid peptides, producing a maximum analgesic effect. This finding was subsequently confirmed in clinical studies, in which patients treated with the alternating-frequency protocol showed a 53% reduction in postoperative morphine requirements, compared with only 32-35% reduction when constant frequencies were used.

The clinical implications of these findings are profound for both patients and clinicians. For patients, especially those suffering from chronic pain such as low back pain or diabetic neuropathic pain, these results offer hope of more effective treatments with fewer side effects compared with conventional medications. The understanding that different frequencies activate different natural pain relief systems allows clinicians to tailor treatments to the specific type of pain of each patient. For clinicians, particularly those working in pain treatment centers, these findings provide a solid scientific basis for integrating electroacupuncture into conventional treatment protocols.

The possibility of significantly reducing the use of pharmaceutical opioids is particularly relevant in the current context of concern about dependence and adverse effects of these medications. In addition, the development of electroacupuncture devices that automatically alternate between different frequencies makes this technique more standardized and reproducible.

It is important to recognize some limitations of this study that should be considered when interpreting the results. First, much of the research was conducted in animal models, and although the clinical studies have confirmed the main findings, additional randomized clinical trials in diverse populations are needed to definitively establish the efficacy and safety of these protocols. In addition, the study focused primarily on mechanisms related to opioid peptides, but other neurotransmitters such as serotonin also play important roles in acupuncture analgesia, suggesting that the mechanisms are even more complex than initially described. The individual variability in treatment response was also not fully explored, and factors such as age, sex, pre-existing medical conditions, and medication use may influence the results.

Considering the overall picture, this research represents an important milestone in the scientific validation of acupuncture and paves the way for promising future developments. The discovery that the central nervous system can distinguish between different stimulation frequencies and respond by releasing different cocktails of natural analgesic substances not only scientifically explains a centuries-old practice but also suggests new therapeutic possibilities. For patients seeking alternatives to conventional pain treatments, especially those concerned about the risks of opioid medications, electroacupuncture emerges as a legitimate, scientifically grounded therapeutic option, offering hope of effective relief through activation of the body's own natural pain control systems.

Strengths

  • 1Robust evidence of the neurobiological mechanisms of electroacupuncture
  • 2Clinical validation of experimental findings in humans
  • 3Innovative discovery regarding specific frequencies and peptide release
  • 4Practical application with the alternating-frequency protocol
⚠️

Limitations

  • 1Review based primarily on studies from the same research group
  • 2Limited quantitative data on the sample sizes of the studies
  • 3Specific focus on opioid mechanisms; other mechanisms less addressed
Prof. Dr. Hong Jin Pai

Expert Commentary

Prof. Dr. Hong Jin Pai

PhD in Sciences, University of São Paulo

Clinical Relevance

Han's work establishes one of the most solid neurobiological foundations for the rational use of electroacupuncture in acute and chronic pain: distinct frequencies recruit distinct endogenous opioid peptides, and the alternating 2/100 Hz protocol simultaneously mobilizes enkephalins, beta-endorphins, endomorphins, and dynorphins. This ceases to be a laboratory curiosity when one considers that this frequency selection can be made at the bedside, in postoperative recovery, or in the chronic pain clinic. The 53% reduction in postoperative morphine consumption with the alternating mode has direct weight in anesthesiology and intensive care, settings in which opioid mitigation reduces nausea, paralytic ileus, and the risk of sensitization. For populations with chronic low back pain, neuropathic pain, or fibromyalgia — where opioidergic polypharmacy carries growing risks — having a protocol with a mechanism proven in human cerebrospinal fluid lends prescribing credibility that transcends the placebo discussion.

Notable Findings

The magnitude of the frequency-dependent response is the most striking finding: 2 Hz increases enkephalin release sevenfold, while 100 Hz doubles dynorphin release — peptide populations with distinct analgesic profiles and receptors (mu/delta versus kappa). What makes this clinically elegant is the confirmation that the central nervous system actively discriminates the afferent information generated by electroacupuncture and does not merely 'detect stimulation.' The superiority of the alternating 2/100 Hz mode over fixed frequencies — 53% versus 32-35% reduction in morphine — demonstrates that the synergistic combination of peptides produces a supra-additive, not merely additive, effect. This replicates, in the endogenous domain, the pharmacological rationale of combining analgesics with complementary mechanisms. The fact that validation was carried out with CSF analysis by radioimmunoassay in humans — and not only in animal models — confers on the mechanistic claims a degree of translational strength rarely seen in the literature of this field.

From My Experience

At the Pain Center of HC-FMUSP, we incorporated the alternating 2/100 Hz protocol as standard for most cases of moderate-to-high intensity chronic pain many years ago, exactly for the logic Han demonstrates: there is no reason to choose only one endogenous opioid pathway when it is possible to recruit them all simultaneously. In my practice, I usually observe perceptible analgesic response from the third or fourth session, with consolidation of the effect between the eighth and twelfth session in patients with chronic low back pain and neuropathic pain. We routinely combine electroacupuncture with supervised exercise programs and, when necessary, with non-opioid analgesics at progressively reduced doses — which dialogues directly with the opioid-sparing data of the article. The patient profile that responds best, in my experience, is the chronic opioid user seeking to taper: simultaneous endocannabinoid and endogenous opioid stimulation appears to smooth the withdrawal process. I avoid the protocol in patients with pacemakers without prior cardiology evaluation and in pregnant women in the first trimester.

Specialist physician in Medical Acupuncture. Adjunct Professor at the Institute of Orthopedics, HC-FMUSP. Coordinator of the Acupuncture Group at the HC-FMUSP Pain Center.

Full original article

Read the full scientific study

Neuroscience Letters · 2004

DOI: 10.1016/j.neulet.2003.12.019

Access original article

Scientific Review

Marcus Yu Bin Pai, MD, PhD

Marcus Yu Bin Pai, MD, PhD

CRM-SP: 158074 | RQE: 65523 · 65524 · 655241

PhD in Health Sciences, University of São Paulo. Board-certified in Pain Medicine, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, and Medical Acupuncture. Scientific review and curation of every entry in this library.

Learn more about the author →
⚕️

Medical disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only and does not replace consultation, diagnosis, or treatment by a qualified professional. Some information may be assisted by artificial intelligence and is subject to inaccuracies. Always consult a physician.

Content reviewed by the medical team at CEIMEC — Integrated Centre for Chinese Medicine Studies, a reference in Medical Acupuncture for over 30 years.