Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses
Main result
2.57points
Pain reduction (VAS) with Acupuncture+Massage
Journal of Pain Research · Ye et al. · 2024 · 2,877 participants
Effectiveness of Complementary and Alternative Medicine in Fibromyalgia Syndrome: A Network Meta-Analysis
Weak
Limited
Moderate
Strong
3.5 points
Sleep improvement (PSQI) with Electroacupuncture
6.9 points
Tender point reduction with Umbilical Acupuncture
Study design sheet
- n=2,877 participants
- High Impact
- Design
- Network Meta-Analysis
- Participants
- 2,877
n = 2,877; median of studies with the same design: 1,449
- Duration
Variable across studies
Studies varied in duration; data collected through April 2023
- OBJECTIVE
- Compare the efficacy of different complementary and alternative therapies in the treatment of fibromyalgia syndrome
- WHO
- 2,877 patients with fibromyalgia across 41 randomized studies
- POINTS
- 20 different modalities including acupuncture, electroacupuncture, massage, moxibustion, and combinations
- Results in numbers
- 2.57 pointsPain reduction (VAS) with Acupuncture+Massage
- 3.5 pointsSleep improvement (PSQI) with Electroacupuncture
- 6.9 pointsTender point reduction with Umbilical Acupuncture
- 6.19 pointsMood improvement (HAMD) with Abdominal Acupuncture
- Outcome comparison
- Visual Analog Scale (VAS) for pain
- Acupuncture + Massage: 77.6 of 100
- Electroacupuncture + Cupping: 75.3 of 100
- Massage: 71.7 of 100
- Sleep quality (PSQI)
- Electroacupuncture: 98.5 of 100
- Massage: 66.5 of 100
- Acupuncture: 51.6 of 100
- Visual Analog Scale (VAS) for pain
What does this mean for you?
This study showed that complementary therapies such as acupuncture and massage are effective and safe for fibromyalgia. The combination of acupuncture with massage was the most effective for reducing pain, while electroacupuncture stood out for improving sleep. These therapies can be considered as safe and effective treatment options.
Article summary
Plain-language narrative summary
Fibromyalgia is a complex medical condition affecting millions of people around the world, characterized by widespread muscle pain, stiffness, and tenderness in muscles, tendons, and joints. This chronic syndrome represents one of the most prevalent rheumatologic disorders, affecting approximately 2% to 4% of the general population, with greater incidence in women and increasing with age. In addition to skeletal muscle pain, which is the most frequently reported symptom, patients face a series of other debilitating manifestations, including sleep disturbances, chronic fatigue, anxiety, depression, and cognitive impairment. The complexity of this condition not only significantly compromises patients' quality of life but also imposes a considerable financial burden, with studies indicating that nearly one quarter of patients find themselves forced to leave employment within five years after diagnosis.
Currently, although conventional treatments include medications such as duloxetine and pregabalin, approved by the FDA (U.S. Food and Drug Administration) for fibromyalgia, there is growing interest in complementary and alternative therapies, especially acupuncture, which was recommended by the European League Against Rheumatism guidelines as first-line treatment.
This study represents the first comprehensive network meta-analysis to evaluate different complementary and alternative medicine treatments for fibromyalgia. The researchers conducted a systematic search of Chinese and English databases from inception through April 2023, focusing on prospective controlled trials examining complementary and alternative therapies in patients with fibromyalgia. The rigorous methodology included only randomized controlled studies published in Chinese or English, with participants diagnosed according to criteria established by the American College of Rheumatology or the Chinese Medical Association. The interventions studied encompassed any complementary and alternative medicine treatment, used alone or in combination, compared with oral medication or conventional treatments.
The primary outcomes assessed included pain improvement via the Visual Analog Scale, sleep quality via the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index, functional impact via the Fibromyalgia Impact Questionnaire, and psychological state via the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale. Statistical analysis was performed using Stata 16.0 software, employing mean differences and 95% confidence intervals, with assessment of literature quality and potential biases.
The research analyzed 41 studies involving 2,877 patients with fibromyalgia and 20 different treatment modalities. The network meta-analysis results revealed significant findings about the efficacy of complementary and alternative therapies. For pain relief, measured by the Visual Analog Scale, the combination of acupuncture with massage emerged as the most effective treatment, presenting a 77.6% probability of reducing pain scores, followed by the combination of electroacupuncture with cupping therapy with 75.3% efficacy. As standalone therapies, massage demonstrated 71.7% efficacy and acupoint application 70.7%.
In the assessment of functional impact via the Fibromyalgia Impact Questionnaire, the acupuncture-massage combination again showed superiority with 99.2% probability of improvement, followed by acupoint application with 86.6%. For reducing the number of tender points, umbilical acupuncture presented the highest efficacy with 85.7% probability, followed by electroacupuncture with 70.3%. As for sleep quality, electroacupuncture demonstrated 98.5% efficacy in reducing Pittsburgh Index scores, while for depressive symptoms, abdominal acupuncture showed 82.2% probability of improvement on Hamilton Scale scores.
The clinical implications of these findings are substantial for both patients and healthcare professionals. The results suggest that complementary and alternative therapies, particularly when combined, offer significant benefits in fibromyalgia management, surpassing conventional treatments in several aspects. For patients, this represents hope for more effective therapeutic options with a better safety profile, since only 6 types of treatments reported adverse reactions, all mild and including skin bruising and dizziness, which resolved without need for additional treatment. The combination of acupuncture with massage emerges as a particularly promising approach for pain relief and functional improvement, while specialized techniques such as umbilical and abdominal acupuncture show specific efficacy for different aspects of the syndrome.
For clinicians, these data provide robust evidence to incorporate complementary therapies into the treatment plan, offering a more holistic approach that addresses not only pain but also the psychological and sleep aspects frequently compromised in fibromyalgia. The demonstrated efficacy of electroacupuncture in sleep improvement and abdominal acupuncture in depressive symptoms suggests that different modalities can be strategically combined to address the multiple aspects of this complex syndrome.
The study has some important limitations that should be considered when interpreting the results. First, inclusion was limited to Chinese and English literature, potentially excluding studies published in other languages and limiting the global perspective of the findings. Additionally, for some therapeutic modalities, only one or two studies were available, which may introduce biases and affect the generalizability of the results. The nature of the interventions makes complete blinding of participants challenging, since external treatments often require interaction between practitioner and patient, potentially influencing perception and response to treatment.
Another limiting aspect is the absence of an established gold standard for fibromyalgia assessment, with measures such as the Visual Analog Scale and the Fibromyalgia Impact Questionnaire depending significantly on patients' subjective experience, raising questions of objectivity. Despite these limitations, the study provides convincing evidence that complementary and alternative therapies, especially when combined, represent safe and effective options for fibromyalgia management. The findings support the European guidelines' recommendation to consider these therapies as first-line treatment, offering patients valuable alternatives to conventional medications, with potential to significantly improve their quality of life through a more comprehensive and personalized approach to the treatment of this complex and debilitating syndrome.
Strengths
- First comprehensive network meta-analysis on complementary medicine in fibromyalgia
- Large sample size with 2,877 participants
- Comparison of 20 different therapeutic modalities
- Assessment of multiple outcomes including pain, sleep, and mood
- High safety profile of the therapies evaluated
Limitations
- Limited to Chinese and English literature only
- Some treatments had few available studies
- Impossibility of completely blinding participants
- Outcome measures dependent on patients' subjective assessment
- Methodological heterogeneity across studies

Expert Commentary
Clinical Relevance
Fibromyalgia remains one of the most demanding challenges in physical medicine and rehabilitation: polysymptomatic patients, partially refractory to duloxetine and pregabalin, with overlapping insomnia and a depressive component that feed back on each other. This network meta-analysis, with 2,877 participants and 20 modalities evaluated, provides the clinician with a quite useful therapeutic map for stratifying technique selection according to the priority outcome. When the dominant complaint is widespread pain and functional impact, the combination of acupuncture with massage presents the highest probability of response. When the patient reports non-restorative sleep as the main limiting factor — a scenario we encounter daily — electroacupuncture stands out. For the depressive component refractory to the usual pharmacological adjustments, abdominal acupuncture offers a now-quantified adjuvant alternative. The safety profile, with adverse reactions reported for only 6 types of treatment, all mild and resolving without additional treatment, reinforces the feasibility of early incorporation of these modalities into the multidisciplinary therapeutic plan.
Notable Findings
Two findings deserve special attention. The first is the performance of the combination of acupuncture with massage, which had the highest ranking probability for pain and function — 99.2% on the Fibromyalgia Impact Questionnaire, where in pairwise comparisons it outperformed, among others, acupuncture alone, massage alone and acupuncture with moxibustion (for pain, the significant difference was only against acupuncture with moxibustion) — suggesting that the synergy between acupoint stimulation and soft tissue mobilization may produce an antinociceptive effect superior to that obtained alone, possibly through simultaneous recruitment of descending inhibitory pathways and reduction of peripheral sensitization. The second noteworthy finding is the efficacy of umbilical acupuncture in reducing tender points, with a 6.9-point reduction and 85.7% probability, the highest in the ranking, ahead of electroacupuncture (70.3%), although without significant differences in pairwise comparisons. This technique is still little explored outside Chinese literature, and its preferential efficacy on tender points warrants mechanistic investigation. The dissociation of efficacy between modalities according to the outcome assessed — sleep, pain, mood, function — is in itself a relevant result, as it validates a personalized and stepwise approach.
From My Experience
In my practice at the musculoskeletal pain outpatient clinic, fibromyalgia represents about a quarter of referrals, and the recurring question is where to start when the patient has already exhausted two or three pharmacological lines. I have observed that the response to acupuncture in this population usually appears between the fourth and sixth sessions, with perceptible improvement first in sleep quality and, subsequently, in overall pain perception — which is consistent with the hierarchy of findings in this meta-analysis. For maintenance, I routinely work with cycles of eight to twelve sessions, progressively spacing them to biweekly as the response consolidates. The combination with aquatic physical therapy and a supervised aerobic exercise program potentiates functional gains in a way that none of the techniques alone achieves. I prefer electroacupuncture when the insomnia component is predominant, and I associate abdominal acupuncture in cases with moderate depressive scores before escalating the antidepressant dose. Patients with severe fibromyalgia, highly deconditioned and with intense catastrophizing, tend to respond more slowly; in those, I start with shorter sessions and gradual stimulus progression so as not to exacerbate allodynia.
Dr. Marcus Yu Bin Pai · MD, PhD · Pain Medicine · Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation · Medical Acupuncture
PhD in Health Sciences, University of São Paulo. Board-certified in Pain Medicine, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, and Medical Acupuncture.
Full original article
Read the full scientific study
Journal of Pain Research · 2024
DOI: 10.2147/JPR.S439906
Scientific review
Dr. Marcus Yu Bin PaiScientific lead · CRM-SP 158074 · RQE 65523 · 65524 · 655241
Medical disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only and does not replace consultation, diagnosis, or treatment by a qualified professional. Some information may be assisted by artificial intelligence and is subject to inaccuracies. Always consult a physician.
Content reviewed by the medical team at CEIMEC — Integrated Centre for Chinese Medicine Studies, a reference in Medical Acupuncture for over 30 years.
- Strong
- Moderate
- Limited
- Weak
See the numbers: This study among the Library’s studies
| Study design | Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses | All studies |
|---|---|---|
| Meta-analysis · Systematic Review | 375 | 387 |
| RCT | 0 | 224 |
| Clinical Guideline | 1 | 5 |
| Observational | 0 | 38 |
| Case Series | 0 | 7 |
| Narrative Review | 2 | 155 |
| Preclinical / Animal | 0 | 6 |
| Other | 27 | 203 |
Related articles
Based on this article’s categories
Clark et al. · Acupuncture in Medicine · 2017
- Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses
- TCM Theory & Diagnostics
- Chronic Pain
Vickers et al. · JAMA · 2014
- Chronic Pain
- Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses
Vickers et al. · The Journal of Pain · 2018
- Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses
- Chronic Pain
Vickers et al. · Archives of Internal Medicine · 2012
- Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses
- Chronic Pain
- Clinical Trial Methodology