Skip to content

Mental Health & Psychiatry

Main result

6.6points

HDRS reduction electroacupuncture

Controlled RCT · Journal of Clinical Psychiatry · Andreescu et al. · 2011 · 53 participants

Acupuncture for the Treatment of Major Depressive Disorder: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Moderate
  • Electroacupuncture28 participants
  • Control acupuncture25 participants
  • 7.6 points

    HDRS reduction control

  • 40 %

    Response rate electroacupuncture

Study design sheet

  • n = 53 participants
  • Neutral result
Design
Controlled RCT
Participants
53

n = 53; median of studies with the same design: 79

Duration

6-8 weeks

12 sessions of 30 minutes over 6-8 weeks

Groups
Each band is proportional to the group’s number of participants, in the order of the list below.
  • Electroacupuncture (28)Needling at GV-20 and Yintang with electrostimulation at 2 Hz
  • Control acupuncture (25)Needling at non-meridian points without electrostimulation
OBJECTIVE
Compare the efficacy of electroacupuncture versus control acupuncture in the treatment of mild to moderate major depression
WHO
53 adults (18-80 years) with mild to moderate major depression, off antidepressant medications
POINTS
GV-20 (vertex of the head) and Yintang (between the eyebrows) for electroacupuncture
Results in numbers
  • 6.6 pointsHDRS reduction electroacupuncture
  • 7.6 pointsHDRS reduction control
  • 40 %Response rate electroacupuncture
  • 44 %Response rate control
  • p = 0.56Statistical difference between groups
Outcome comparison
  • Reduction in HDRS score
    • Electroacupuncture: 6.6 of 20
    • Control: 7.6 of 20

What does this mean for you?

This study tested whether acupuncture with electrical stimulation works better than acupuncture without stimulation for treating depression. Surprisingly, both treatments improved depressive symptoms equally, suggesting that acupuncture may have benefits, but not necessarily through the specific points tested.

Article summary

Plain-language narrative summary

This randomized controlled trial investigated the efficacy of electroacupuncture in the treatment of major depression, a condition that affects up to 20% of the adult population and frequently shows resistance to conventional treatments. With more than 50% of patients not tolerating or not responding adequately to antidepressants, complementary therapies such as acupuncture have generated increasing interest. The research was conducted from March 2004 to May 2007 at the University of Pittsburgh, with 53 participants aged 18 to 80 years diagnosed with mild to moderate major depression. Participants were randomized to two groups: active electroacupuncture (28 people) using GV-20 and Yintang with 2 Hz electrical stimulation, and control acupuncture (25 people) with needling at non-meridian points without electrical stimulation.

All participants discontinued psychotropic medications before the study and received 12 sessions of 30 minutes over 6-8 weeks. The primary outcome was measured by the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS), administered weekly by blinded assessors. The results were surprising: both groups showed significant and equivalent improvement in depressive symptoms. The electroacupuncture group had a mean reduction of 6.6 points on the HDRS (37.5% relative improvement), while the control group showed a reduction of 7.6 points (41.3% improvement).

There was no statistically significant difference between the groups (p = 0.56). Clinical response rates were also similar: 40% in electroacupuncture versus 44% in control. Both treatments were well tolerated, with no serious adverse events. Safety was similar between groups, measured by the UKU scale.

There were no significant differences in functional improvement, anxiety symptoms, or sleep disturbances between the groups. The researchers interpreted these results considering several methodological limitations. First, the control group may not have been truly inert, since in traditional Chinese medicine the entire scalp region is considered a therapeutic microsystem. Second, the standardized protocol with only two points may have been insufficient compared with the individualized clinical practice of acupuncture.

Third, the dosage may have been inadequate compared with Chinese studies that used more intensive protocols. The authors conclude that a specific effect of electroacupuncture could not be demonstrated; the improvement in both groups may be due to a placebo effect, and needling at non-acupuncture points may have physiologic effects detectable by functional neuroimaging. This finding aligns with other North American studies that showed similar results between active and control acupuncture, contrasting with Chinese studies in which acupuncture or electroacupuncture was as efficacious as, or more efficacious than, amitriptyline or maprotiline. The study contributes to the understanding that the effects of acupuncture on depression may be more complex than initially presumed, involving both specific and non-specific components.

Future research could explore three-group designs, including individualized protocols according to traditional Chinese medicine, controls with non-penetrating needles, and a greater number of points. The data support the tolerability of electroacupuncture in the treatment of mild to moderate major depression, but do not allow a specific effect of the technique to be claimed.

Strengths

  • Well-structured randomized controlled design
  • Blinded assessors
  • Standardized and validated measures
  • Systematic monitoring of adverse events
  • Intention-to-treat analysis

Limitations

  • Initial error in the treatment of 4 participants
  • Control group may not have been truly inert
  • Standardized protocol limited to only 2 points
  • Relatively small sample size
  • Exclusion of patients on psychotropic medications
Prof. Dr. Hong Jin Pai

Expert Commentary

Clinical Relevance

Major depression represents one of the most persistent challenges in outpatient clinical practice, especially when the patient reports intolerance or unsatisfactory response to conventional antidepressants. This work by Andreescu and colleagues raises a question that any physician working with acupuncture must address seriously: what is the real magnitude of the specific effect of the points we choose? The fact that both groups — electroacupuncture at GV-20 and Yintang versus needling at non-meridian points — showed a significant and comparable decrease in Hamilton scale scores makes it impossible to attribute the improvement to a specific effect of the points: the authors acknowledge a placebo effect and a control that may not be inert. For the physician treating patients with mild to moderate depression who refuse or do not tolerate psychotropic drugs, this study supports only the tolerability of electroacupuncture: the authors were not able to demonstrate a specific effect and consider it possible that the improvement is due to a placebo effect.

Notable Findings

What stands out in this trial is not the absence of difference between the groups, but the magnitude of the response within each group: reductions of 6.6 and 7.6 points on the Hamilton scale in 6 to 8 weeks occurred in both groups, and the authors consider it possible that the beneficial effect is due solely to a placebo effect. Response rates were 40% and 44%, with no significant difference between the groups. The finding that points outside the classic meridians produced an equivalent result to the active protocol is compatible, according to the authors, with a control that is not inert: needling at non-acupuncture points may have physiologic effects detectable by functional neuroimaging. The uniform safety profile between the groups, without serious adverse events, reinforces the feasibility of the method in psychiatric populations.

From My Experience

In my practice, when I receive patients with a diagnosis of mild to moderate major depression referred from psychiatry — frequently because they do not tolerate the side effects of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors — I usually work with protocols that go well beyond two points. GV-20 and Yintang are points I use systematically, but I combine them with points of the Spleen and Kidney meridians according to the individual energetic diagnostic pattern, which makes it difficult to directly compare my practice with the protocol of this trial. I have observed that the first subjective response — improvement in sleep and associated anxiety — usually appears between the third and fifth sessions. For stabilization, I typically work with 12 to 16 sessions in the acute phase, followed by monthly maintenance. The patient profile that best responds, in my experience, is one with reactive depression, good capacity for introspection, and who seeks acupuncture as an ally — not as a desperate last resort. The combination with supervised physical activity consistently potentiates the results.

Prof. Dr. Hong Jin Pai · PhD in Sciences, University of São Paulo

Specialist physician in Medical Acupuncture. Adjunct Professor at the Institute of Orthopedics, HC-FMUSP. Coordinator of the Acupuncture Group at the HC-FMUSP Pain Center.

Front view
Rear view
  • 1HeadEX-HN3
Where the cited points areBody regions with at least one cited point, from each point’s region in the atlas; on the trunk, front or back by channel. The drawing shows regions, not the exact spot of each point; limbs, head and neck show in both views. Each point is shown just below.
See the numbers: Where the cited points are
RegionPointsCodes
Head1EX-HN3

Points cited

Full original article

Read the full scientific study

Journal of Clinical Psychiatry · 2011

DOI: 10.4088/JCP.10m06105

Access original article

Scientific review

Medical disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only and does not replace consultation, diagnosis, or treatment by a qualified professional. Some information may be assisted by artificial intelligence and is subject to inaccuracies. Always consult a physician.

Content reviewed by the medical team at CEIMEC — Integrated Centre for Chinese Medicine Studies, a reference in Medical Acupuncture for over 30 years.

  • Strong
  • Moderate
  • Limited
  • Weak
19801990200020102020
This study among the Library’s studiesEach dot is a study: left to right, the publication year; top to bottom, the study design, from meta-analyses to preclinical work; colour and shape give the level of evidence. Highlighted: the Mental Health & Psychiatry studies.
See the numbers: This study among the Library’s studies
Study designMental Health & PsychiatryAll studies
Meta-analysis · Systematic Review25387
RCT21224
Clinical Guideline05
Observational138
Case Series07
Narrative Review8155
Preclinical / Animal06
Other5203
See the Mental Health & Psychiatry studies in the Library

Related articles

Based on this article’s categories

  1. Yin et al. · JAMA Network Open · 2022

    • Electroacupuncture
    • Mental Health & Psychiatry
  2. Han et al. · Chinese Medicine · 2021

    • Electroacupuncture
    • Mental Health & Psychiatry
    • Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses
  3. Chen et al. · Research in Nursing & Health · 2023

    • Mental Health & Psychiatry
    • Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses
    • Electroacupuncture
  4. Zeng et al. · Medicine · 2018

    • Electroacupuncture
    • Mental Health & Psychiatry
    • Addiction & Substance Abuse