Skip to content

Auricular Acupuncture

RCT - Controlled Trial · Substance Abuse Treatment, Prevention, and Policy · Ahlberg et al. · 2016 · 280 participants

Auricular acupuncture for substance use: a randomized controlled trial of effects on anxiety, sleep, drug use and use of addiction treatment services

Moderate
  • NADA80 participants
  • Local Protocol80 participants
  • p=0.229

    Between-group difference in anxiety

  • Yes

    Improvement in anxiety (BAI) - all groups

  • Yes

    Improvement in sleep (ISI) - all groups

Study design sheet

  • n=280 participants
  • Negative Result
Design
RCT - Controlled Trial
Participants
280

n = 280; median of studies with the same design: 79

Duration

5 weeks of treatment

5 weeks of treatment with 3-month follow-up

Groups
Each band is proportional to the group’s number of participants, in the order of the list below.
  • NADA (80)Auricular acupuncture NADA protocol (15 sessions)
  • Local Protocol (80)Auricular acupuncture local protocol (10 sessions)
  • Control (120)Relaxation with music
OBJECTIVE
To assess the effects of auricular acupuncture on anxiety, sleep, drug use, and service utilization in adults with substance use disorder
WHO
280 adults with substance use disorder and psychiatric comorbidity
POINTS
NADA protocol: Sympathetic, Shen Men, Kidney, Liver, and Lung
Results in numbers
  • YesImprovement in anxiety (BAI) - all groups
  • YesImprovement in sleep (ISI) - all groups
  • p=0.229Between-group difference in anxiety
  • p=0.065Between-group difference in sleep
  • 57 %Dropout rate
Outcome comparison
  • Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI) - reduction T1 to T3
    • NADA: 7.2 of 63
    • Local Protocol: 6.3 of 63
    • Control: 11.7 of 63
  • Insomnia Severity Index (ISI) - reduction T1 to T3
    • NADA: 2.5 of 28
    • Local Protocol: 5.2 of 28
    • Control: 6 of 28

What does this mean for you?

This study showed that both auricular acupuncture and simple relaxation helped reduce anxiety and improve sleep in people with substance use disorder. However, there was no significant difference between treatments, suggesting that therapeutic support itself may be more important than the specific technique.

Article summary

Plain-language narrative summary

This randomized controlled trial investigated the efficacy of auricular acupuncture in treating anxiety symptoms, sleep problems, drug use, and health service utilization in adults with substance use disorder and psychiatric comorbidity. The research was conducted at an addiction clinic in Örebro, Sweden, between October 2010 and June 2014. The 280 participants were randomized into three groups: auricular acupuncture following the NADA protocol (15 sessions), auricular acupuncture following an adapted local protocol (10 sessions), and a control group receiving relaxation with music. The NADA protocol used five specific auricular points (Sympathetic, Shen Men, Kidney, Liver, and Lung), considered ideal for patients with addiction problems.

Primary outcomes were anxiety (measured by the Beck Anxiety Inventory - BAI) and insomnia (measured by the Insomnia Severity Index - ISI), assessed at baseline, after 5 weeks, and after 3 months. Results showed that all three groups had significant improvements in anxiety symptoms and sleep problems over time. In the NADA group, the BAI score decreased by 7.2 points; in the local protocol, it decreased by 6.3 points; and in the control group, it decreased by 11.7 points between baseline and the 3-month follow-up. For the ISI, reductions were 2.5, 5.2, and 6.0 points, respectively.

Critically, there were no statistically significant differences between groups in any of the primary or secondary outcomes. Effect sizes were small (η²=0.03 for BAI and η²=0.05 for ISI). Regarding substance use, only about 9-12% of participants reported relapse to alcohol or other drug use at follow-ups, with no significant differences between groups. The study faced an important limitation: a high dropout rate (57% of participants dropped out before the 3-month follow-up).

Participants who remained in the study were older, more often inpatients, and completed more treatment sessions. The clinical implications suggest that auricular acupuncture, as administered in this study, did not prove more effective than simple relaxation for anxiety, sleep, or substance use problems. The authors interpret that the effects observed across all groups may be attributable to nonspecific therapeutic factors, such as the support provided by regular contact with healthcare professionals, or regression-to-the-mean effects. This finding is consistent with previous systematic reviews that failed to find robust evidence for acupuncture in substance use disorder treatment.

The study has important strengths, including the use of a relatively unselected sample of inpatients and outpatients, conferring high external validity, and a design that included an adequate control group to control for nonspecific therapeutic factors.

Strengths

  • Large and diverse sample with high external validity
  • Well-structured randomized controlled design
  • Use of standardized and validated instruments
  • Adequate control for nonspecific factors

Limitations

  • High dropout rate (57%)
  • Sample size smaller than calculated
  • Absence of placebo group with sham needles
  • No correction for multiple comparisons
Prof. Dr. Hong Jin Pai

Expert Commentary

Clinical Relevance

The management of anxiety and insomnia in patients with substance use disorder represents one of the most arduous challenges in clinical practice, especially when psychiatric comorbidities are present and the pharmacological arsenal is limited by the risk of interactions or reinforcement of the addictive pattern. In this scenario, any nonpharmacological intervention that produces benefit — even if nonspecific — has a legitimate place in the therapeutic plan. What this trial shows is that all three groups — auricular acupuncture by the NADA protocol, the local protocol, and relaxation with music — improved in anxiety and sleep over five weeks and three months, with no significant differences between them. The authors consider nonspecific effects the most plausible interpretation, note a possible contribution of regression to the mean, and conclude that there is no evidence that acupuncture as delivered in the study is more effective than relaxation; the design had no no-intervention group and there was 57% attrition at three months. For the physician treating this population, the central finding is not the equivalence between groups but the improvement of the cohort as a whole, which the authors consider most plausibly nonspecific, without being able to attribute it to auricular acupuncture; the authors conclude that the results raise questions about the clinical use of acupuncture in patients with substance use problems.

Notable Findings

The data point that deserves redoubled attention is the magnitude of the reduction in the control group: an 11.7-point drop on the BAI and 6.0 points on the ISI over three months, numerically surpassing both auricular acupuncture groups. The authors interpret this pattern as compatible with nonspecific effects, such as the support provided and regression to the mean, rather than as proof of a real effect of auricular acupuncture or of structured contact. The small effect sizes (η² of 0.03 and 0.05) reflect the homogeneity of responses among the three groups, not the absence of improvement. Additionally, the relapse rate to substance use was between 9% and 12% across all groups during follow-ups — a low value for this population, which the authors attribute to those who relapsed probably being over-represented among the dropouts and to being drug free being a requirement for treatment at the center. The study did not assess or report adverse events, safety, or tolerability.

From My Experience

In my practice with patients in addiction rehabilitation, auricular acupuncture by the NADA protocol has been a consistent resource for managing craving, agitation, and insomnia, especially during the first weeks of abstinence. I usually observe an initial response — perceptible reduction in anxiety and improvement in sleep — within the first three to five sessions, which coincides with what this trial indirectly suggests through the temporal trajectory of the groups. In general, I work with cycles of ten to fifteen sessions in the acute phase, followed by biweekly maintenance based on progression. Combination with relaxation techniques, cognitive-behavioral therapy, and, when necessary, pharmacotherapy is what has produced the best results throughout my trajectory in this area. The profile that responds best, in my observation, is the patient with prominent anxiety and maintenance insomnia who still maintains a connection with the service — exactly the subgroup that completed more sessions in this study. Patients who are very disorganized or in acute severe withdrawal crisis need prior stabilization before fully benefiting from auricular acupuncture.

Prof. Dr. Hong Jin Pai · PhD in Sciences, University of São Paulo

Specialist physician in Medical Acupuncture. Adjunct Professor at the Institute of Orthopedics, HC-FMUSP. Coordinator of the Acupuncture Group at the HC-FMUSP Pain Center.

Full original article

Read the full scientific study

Substance Abuse Treatment, Prevention, and Policy · 2016

DOI: 10.1186/s13011-016-0068-z

Access original article

Scientific review

Medical disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only and does not replace consultation, diagnosis, or treatment by a qualified professional. Some information may be assisted by artificial intelligence and is subject to inaccuracies. Always consult a physician.

Content reviewed by the medical team at CEIMEC — Integrated Centre for Chinese Medicine Studies, a reference in Medical Acupuncture for over 30 years.

  • Strong
  • Moderate
  • Limited
  • Weak
19801990200020102020
This study among the Library’s studiesEach dot is a study: left to right, the publication year; top to bottom, the study design, from meta-analyses to preclinical work; colour and shape give the level of evidence. Highlighted: the Auricular Acupuncture studies.
See the numbers: This study among the Library’s studies
Study designAuricular AcupunctureAll studies
Meta-analysis · Systematic Review8387
RCT20224
Clinical Guideline05
Observational138
Case Series07
Narrative Review5155
Preclinical / Animal06
Other5203
See the Auricular Acupuncture studies in the Library

Related articles

Based on this article’s categories

  1. Stuyt EB · Acupuncture in Medicine · 2014

    • Auricular Acupuncture
    • Addiction & Substance Abuse
    • Mental Health & Psychiatry
  2. Karst et al. · Anesthesia & Analgesia · 2007

    • Mental Health & Psychiatry
    • Auricular Acupuncture
  3. Rodrigues et al. · JAMA Network Open · 2023

    • Auricular Acupuncture
    • Mental Health & Psychiatry
  4. Zeng et al. · Medicine · 2018

    • Electroacupuncture
    • Mental Health & Psychiatry
    • Addiction & Substance Abuse